Balloon and Stone Throwing in Spring Valley Were NOT Accidents; Bias Was on Behalf the Throwers

The following was cross psoted by www.vosisneias.com Direct Link:  http://www.vosizneias.com/85700/2011/06/17/rockland-county-ny-spring-valley-village-clerk-says-assaulted-by-chasidim-threatens-to-sue

 

Local media are reporting that an African America from Spring Valley NY may sue after her children were hit by Jews moments after – as she says – one of her children accidently threw a water balloon on a passing car. The stories suggest that the driver jumped out of the car, ran after an 11 year old and started hitting the kid. Soon, dozens of Jews joined in the attack.

This narrative is false. Here are the facts:

Wednesday June 15 at 10:45, a motorist took a turn off Monsey Blvd onto Fletcher in Spring Valley New York. The driver, a Jew, suddenly got physically hit by something that flew into his car through an open window. After swerving and then gaining controlling of his car, the driver pulled into a Parking Lot in the area and contacted Chaverim of Rockland; a volunteer service organization of the local Jewish Community. After arriving, the members noticed it was a water balloon that was thrown at the car. After speculating if it was a mistake or a dangerous game by some, Chaverim observed from a covert location that youngsters are indeed waiting alongside the road, inching for trouble. However, cars driven by non-Jews were not attacked until a Volunteer of Chaverim passed and his car was hit by water balloons and small stones too.

After observing this, the members contacted the Police Department and ran after the perpetrators to try identify them for PD. Not wanting to physically hold down a minor and be subject to chargers, a few Volunteers obstructed the entrance of a house in an effort to prevent the youngsters from disappearing inside. At the same time, many African Americans at the scene started pushing and shoving the Jews in an effort to permit the perpetrators – who obviously were not supervised by responsible adults – to enter inside, and thus make it difficult to hold them accountable. This caused a physical struggle between the sides. At the time the Police arrived, they charged one member of the Jewish community and ticked another one for this scuffle.

Based on media reports, the parent is working with the NAACP and considering suing. In the mean time, some locals – including myself who was raised in a single parent household yet B”H never threw stones at passing cars - hope that instead of lawsuits, parents will spend time 1) keeping tabs on their youngsters at the night hours; 2) teaching them to not play dangerous games against motor vehicles, and 3) to give them an upbringing that does not cause them to racially distinguish between Jewish and non-Jewish drivers/people.

contact yossi@yossigestetner.com

  • Mo

    That whole housing complex doesn’t belong in that area.

    There is a host of shady activity going in there, including drugs & prostitution. A few years ago a young frum girl was raped there.

    I have once been in one of those apartments, they are old and dilapidated and as a result attracts an undesirable crowd.

    I believe it’s jewish owned and was probably built before most monsey residents lived there.

  • http://gravatar.com/saramaimon saramaimon

    I have once been in one of those apartments, they are old and dilapidated and as a result attracts an undesirable crowd….
    I believe it’s jewish owned.”

    uhh then shouldn’t you be complaining to your fellow jews about the conditions there?

    I note that gestetner’s listing of the facts is not too dissimilar from the journal news’s- it seems that the facts aren’t much in dispute. Some bratty kids engaging in aggressive behavior, possibly targeting chassidim/jews. But gestetner seems to think that justifies 40 men attacking the kid’s family. Seem the me that the chaverim are guiltier of a bias crime- if they were jewish kids, or even non jewish white upper class kids, you would have either ignored them, talked to the kid’s parent, or at most, called the police who are actually TRAINED to handle this stuff.

    • Mo

      Sara,

      I didn’t complain, I leave that to the NAACP.

  • m

    its outrageous how these false story circulated the media. remember rhe story in new square? watch out! the people who publish and enjoy the negative media coverage need to realize an ordinary gentile or evem an american jew dosn’t distinguish between hassidim.

  • Yoel Mechanic

    Frankly, I don’t know who to believe. On the news, we hear the mother of the child give her side of the story. However on the other side the above report is not correctly written. Although it sounds plausible, we are asked to presume that it was eye witnesses or members of Chaverim who were at the scene giving there testimony. However no where is it explicitly stated what the source of the information is: it is just insinuated that the source is “someone who really knows” It would be worthwhile to follow the old fashioned tried and true journalistic standards.

  • http://www.maimonfamily.net saramaimon

    addendum: the self righteous suggestion from frum people to the mother who was assaulted, that she educate her kids “not to racially differentiate” is so laughable; which of the group goes to school and work together with people from every race, religion and ethnicity and which live in a completely segregated world?

  • Yossi Gestetner

    Hey saramaimon. Jews work with members of other races at all times, be it Black or Hisponic. Same is with Jews who are looking for more education, attened classes attened by people of all stripes.

    Besides, people of ALL races and relions tend to stick to their own. However, sticking to a Community does not mean people are hatefull to others along racial lines.

  • Monsey Luke

    It was wrong that the police were not called immediately and it was wrong of Trustee Gross to interfere. We have laws in place and one should avail themselves to them. We do not need this kind of press and it could have ALL been avoided if we played by the rules. Monsey Luke.

    • Yossi Gestetner

      The Police WAS called early on but they didnt want to respond because to them it was nothing major. Only after it go into a pushing fight, they they come flying in. Gross, as any person, had the right to ask that this should not be blown out of proportion.

  • Monsey Luke

    We can respectfully disagree. The police are required to respond to every call to the dispatcher. Gross as a Village Official does not have the right to infer with police matters as he votes as a Trustee on police matters. Thanks for the opportunity to comment.

    • Yossi Gestetner

      What the Police is required to do and what they actually do may be two things. Feel me? Gross, again didnt interfer. He stated his opinion and done. Are we in Communist Russia?

  • Luke

    “Are we in Communist Russia?”
    No, actually we are in the United States and more specifically, New York State. Government officials must walk a very fine line. Interference with the police department investigation by urging one of the parties “not to press charges” when you are known to that party to be a Village official, is crossing that line. Thanks for the opportunity to comment.

  • suri

    There is a host of shady activity going in there, including drugs & prostitution. A few years ago a young frum girl was raped there.

    She was probably teasing