Hurricane Irene = The Jewish Katrina!

Two of the at least three people who – at the time of this writing – died in New York from Hurricane Irene were Orthodox/Hasidic Jews.

One was a forty six year old from Spring Valley NY. It started when a six year old boy went Sunday 11:00 AM to a gate that separates his corner lawn and a low-laying sidewalk where a small puddle has formed. The boy didn’t know that a live wire was lying in that puddle. He stepped into it and waves started hitting him. A passing father of four drove by; pulled over across the street and ran to help. He got electrocuted and died there on the side of the road, while the boy was left in a critical condition with diminished hope that his hands will be usable (H”Y). The boy’s father – also there trying to help his son – was taken into hospital for a few hours due to burns on his left arm.

The story actually started hours earlier at 3:00 AM when a transformer at that corner exploded into a massive fire ball. The local utility company “Orange and Rockland” and local FD arrived to assist. After O&R apparently and according to local elected officials assured the Fire Department that all was safe, they left and the rest is history.

The other tragedy took place at the Valkyrie Motel in Fleischmann’s New York. Vacationers were stranded in five-ten foot deep water for hours upon hours with limited rescuers in site. National Guard and other personnel were indeed there for hours just as they were over New Orleans a few hours after the Hurricane hit. But the work today – just as after Katrina – didn’t seem to fit the need: A seventy year old woman passed away Sunday afternoon while many others were traumatized from being besieged in Katrina-like conditions until late Sunday afternoon in or surrounded by water.

The Fleischmann’s incident reminded me of what took place eight weeks ago when my mother was trapped in flash-flood, four-five deep water in her then-apartment in Monsey, NY. Her multiple calls to 911 didn’t yield any results. It was only the brave work of volunteers of Chaverim of Rockland who swam into the deep water when they got the call that saved her life. (Insurance, of course didn’t cover any losses. When DO they cover anything? It was up to private contributions and help – not a dollar of government assistance – that put my mother back on her feet.)

While rabbinical leaders will ask that Jews repent from their sins, the Jewish Community will be waiting for answers since we know that no one should rely on miracles. Yes, prayers are a first but actions by humans need to follow. If a local utility company is clueless despite all the costly government regulations and if state/federal governments are poorly organized to handle a disaster despite all the hype, tragedy is destined to happen.

contact: yossi@yossigestetner.com

  • Burech Miller

    The Jewish Katrina? I have read some absurd things on here, but that has to be the most insane thing I have ever heard. How are two people dying at all comparable to almost 1,500 people dying over a period of almost a week of failed response?

  • Yossi Gestetner

    For the family of Stern she died. She is gone. It is no differnce how many more people died. Besides, Satmar BP Yeshiva is located at that camp. Gov sent them to a shelter that has NO beds!!!

  • http://twitter.com/Ramapo52 Ramapo Politics (@Ramapo52)

    Yossi wow great article but quite ovethe top Starting with the whole Katrina like and then the story with your mother that people swam to rescue her. Really? Where you even there? I dont think so!!!

    • Yossi Gestetner

      What is over the top about Katrina? Thousands of Jews are stuck or rained in today with water and blackouts, plus the massive siaster in Fleischmann’s.

      Rgearding my mom. Well… I saw the pics and also got first hand reports from volunteers and reguler people who back it up.

      Bottem line is: We rely on Gov, but it is not worth much in most cases.

      I mean, be honest: How many people who got trees on thier house/roads, blackouts or floodings the last 24 hours know or have seen a dime from or about FEMA? This whole thing of “FEMA doing a good or a bad job” is for TV political shows; has zero in real life besides them showing up a week later and thiking of sending you trailers you dont need.

  • Burech Miller

    Your opinion is based on an emotional appeal that has no basis in reality. I am sorry, but it is not the job of the government to take care of the Satmar yeshiva. The yeshiva knew for many days, as did the rest of us, that the hurricane was coming. They had the opportunity to plan for something if they had the intention of evacuating.

  • Yossi Gestetner

    Your thinking can be used on the people of New Orleans too.

    BTW, 53% of those who died in Luissiana due to Katrina, were Blacks. Am sure you ‘knew’ the number is probably 90 percent. A?

  • Burech Miller

    I do agree with this logic in regard to New Orleans. It is not the job of people living in Minnesota to pay to take people out of harm’s way in New Orleans. If people on a local level would like to levy a tax to create a fund to assist one another in evacuating from a hurricane, or people elsewhere would like to donate to that fund, then that is fine, because people directly impacted and volunteers are the ones paying for it. I have heard more stories of people who stayed during Katrina making it out on their own or with the help of capable neighbors and civilian strangers, than stories of the government getting people out.

    It happens to be that I was in New Orleans during Hurricane Katrina, and I did not depend upon the government to get me out. I also worked at a shelter in the immediate aftermath. This shelter was run by the American branch of the International Red Cross, not by the US government. The shelter was incredibly large, and took most of the post-flood evacuees, and the majority that I saw were brought in my private citizens.

    The incredible loss of life, destruction of infrastructure, and chaos in the aftermath is a creation of the dependence upon government (specifically federal) that has been created by our notion that the government is supposed to be our babysitter from cradle to grave. This is continued by the policies of both political parties, and works until the government actually has to deliver. The government should officially stop trying to babysit citizens, and stop trying to protect citizens from themselves, because we clearly see that the government is unable to deliver. Government agencies should be run at the local level, and most things should indeed be privatized to provide better service.

  • http://WHOISTHETHIRDPERSONTHATWASKILLEDINTHENYHURRICANE? MEYER

    WHO WAS THE THIED PERSON THAT WAS KILLED IN NY ?

    • Yossi Gestetner

      a woman was swepped away.

  • Shaya

    Yossi

    Utter nonsense comparing to Katrina. You sat down to write an article to compare this to Katrina?

    Or you have no idea what happened at Katrina or you are a delussinial demegog.

    Stupidity is an understatement.

    Don’t be angry next time when others compare their stories to the holocaust.

    • Yossi Gestetner

      I wont take you to court if your brain does not ‘get’ a larger point. Read my replies here to someone else here on this post. It may help you

  • yic

    the gov.is here for P.R.and not to help pepole and about what burich miller says that they knew its coming food stemps is olso possible for a big % of pepole to take a job and even so the gov is helping them (to stay with out a job)why dosent the gov say for them that we are warning you take a job to make sure that you have bread and btw in flishmans they didn’t say it will be so bad thanx yossi great article

  • Pingback: make money fast