Category Archives: Opinion

Ulysses Grant, a Hero of the Jews?

His December 1862 order expelling Jews is known until today but Jeff Jacoby has an interesting look at it:

Notwithstanding its sweeping terms, the order turned out to have little immediate impact on the thousands of Jews living in the area under Grant’s command. Only about 100 Jews were uprooted, primarily in northern Mississippi and in Paducah, Kentucky. Grant’s expulsion order had no discernible effect on the war or on his own military career, either. Lincoln later promoted him to lieutenant general — a rank previously held only by George Washington — and named him commander of all Union armies. Grant became a national hero, and was twice elected president…

More striking by far was the order’s long-term effect on Grant himself. He came to deeply regret what he had done, and went to great lengths to make amends — so much so that the eight years of the Grant administration would prove to be the first golden age for American Jewry. As president, Grant appointed more Jews to public office than any of his predecessors and displayed remarkable sensitivity to the plight of persecuted Jews abroad. At his death in 1885, Grant was fervently mourned in the nation’s synagogues. “Seldom before,” one Jewish newspaper remarked at the time, “has the Kaddish been repeated so universally for a non-Jew as in this case.”

24 Hours Before Urgent Vote, Detracters Smear Orthodox Jewish School Board Members

Tax increases in the last three years are very low compared to the previous years, yet school graduation levels are very high compared to previous years.

I am talking about the East Ramapo Central School district in Rockland County New York that produces more with less. Read more »

WSJ Video: Is U.S. Military Ready for Conflict With Iran?

Op-Ed: Five Reasons Why DA Charles Hynes Is Right

The Job of the District Attorney is to prosecute criminals and get them off the streets, so the public is protected from them. Every DA has to come up with unique ideas how to tackle criminals in his jurisdiction. The crimes of many jurisdictions are different than others, and the criminals of many jurisdictions are different than others.

In DA Hynes’ Jurisdiction there’s the largest concentration of orthodox Jews in the entire Unites States, there was a unique problem with a certain type of crime and criminals in DA Hynes’ jurisdiction – sex abuse in the orthodox Jewish community.

Because of the history of the Jewish community, its members had certain issues with reporting crime to the authorities and specifically sex crimes. Some people had issues with Mesira (reporting a fellow Jew to non Jewish authorities) in general, but even more people had issues with reporting sex crimes, for several reasons, and I’ll list some of those: Read more »

I Congratulate Reporters Who Hold DA Hynes’ Feet to the Fire Re Orthodox Jewish Crimes

Many reporters and journalists in NYC and beyond ran recently stories regarding Brooklyn D.A. Charles Hynes. The issue is the DA does not want to release the names of a few dozen Orthodox Jews who were arrested in the last three years for allegedly violating minors. The DA says that as long a person (in the Orthodox Jewish Community) is not found guilty, the name should not be released because the insular Orthodox Community will easily find out the name of the victim, thus reducing the chance that the victim would want to continue helping in the prosecution. Read more »

‘Bibi Was Heading for a Cliff’ and Needed Unity to Survive

J.J. Goldberg Argues: Bibi was headed for a cliff and Mofaz offered him a lifeline that saves them  both — in exchange for a hefty turn to the left. Sound impossible? Actually,  it’s nigh inescapable.
Read more:

First, consider the polls. Three different polls released a week before the  unity bombshell showed Netanyahu emerging from a September election with the  biggest Knesset bloc by far, a commanding 31 seats in the 120-seat house, versus  18 for Labor, the runner-up. Unfortunately, the polls also showed him with a  unstable coalition of 61 seats, tops.

Even more alarming was the May 6 Likud convention, where Bibi unexpectedly  found himself outflanked by a large, well-organized pro-settler right.  Associates say he feared if he won in  September he’d end up “a hostage” to  extremists unless he found new allies. Read more »

Matt Brooks of RJC Responds To The AJC Jewish Voters Poll

My Piece in The Jewish Voice: As the general election has just kicked off, with the economy getting the main focus and attention, and President Barrack Obama taking some hits on his record, it is also important to see how American voters view President Obama’s conduct and his handling of issues that matter to most Americans.
Let’s look specifically at a demographic that may play a vital role in determining who becomes the next President of the U.S. this November – the Jewish American voter. Since this race is going to likely come down to a battle over swing states, those that historically and demographically choose the President, the Jewish population in Florida, Ohio, Philadelphia and Cleveland could be the demographic giving Mitt Romney the edge over the President. Read more »

Brooklyn – Memo to Dem Boss Lopez Regarding the Satmar Camp Dispute

In an interview with NY1, Democratic Assemblyman and Brooklyn Dem Party boss Veto Lopez explained his position in the ongoing Satmar Camp dispute in Upstate New York. Among others he said, “The overwhelming number of people, if majority rules and 80 percent of them are in need and support this, it’s sad that she [Congresswoman Velasquez] has taken the minority position.” In other words claims the Boss, most children attending the camps belong to the Zalman side of the dispute and since “Majority Rules,” the Zaloynem shall have control of the camps. Read more »

Reason Six for the Unity Government in Israel

Bibi wants to be able to say to President Obama: More than three-quarters of the Knesset is with me. I am Israel. – Reason number six by Jeffrey Goldberg why Israel went to a Coalition government, giving Bibi 94 of the 120 seats in Knesset.

Will Iran Ban the Use of Motorcycles to Avoid Scientists from Being Killed by Israel?

New Jersey lawmakers want to pass a law banning people under the age of eighteen to enter tanning salons, following the bizarre incident of a mother who took along a five year old to a Salon. This ‘lets-pass-a-law-or-regulation’ reaction is similar to the rule that passengers can’t be covered with a blanket the last half hour of a flight because the underwear bomber was covered with a blanket… Similarly, fluids were for years not permitted to be used and shows were taken off from 90 year old in wheelchair because of the 2002 show bomb plot.

This sort of response by lawmakers and politicians in America has led my friend to ask me if Iran will ban the use of motorcycles to deny Israel the ability to kill its scientists by using motor cycles… you know, as if this is the problem and reason why Iranians are being taken out by Israel…

The Recent AJC Poll Did Not Survey Jewish Voters

No, I am not suggesting that Reform or Conservative Jews who made up large portions of the recent AJC poll are not Jewish. But yes, I am saying an obvious thing about the AJC Poll that slipped the minds of most people: The sample surveyed were Jewish Adults in the United States, and not necessarily Registered Voters and certainly not exclusively Likely Voters.

What’s the difference? Well, for an incumbent, the best polling numbers are when surveying every day people; regardless if they plan on voting or not. The second-best class for an incumbent is ‘Registered Voters’ who are more tuned into politics than regular adults and tend to have more reservations about elected officials than regular adults. The worst class of polling for a sitting politician are the ‘Likely Voters’; those who follow politics closely and plan on taking part in the process in November.

To the best of my knowledge, the AJC poll showing President Obama gaining 61% of the Jewish Vote is based on everyday Jewish adults. This means, Obama’s numbers are quite lower among likely Jewish Voters than the 61% showing Obama retained in the recent poll. Is it below fifty percent? No. But it certainly is below sixty percent.

[In Defense of] Obama’s 2′nd Foot-on-Table Moment with Netanyahu

On Wednesday morning, the White House issued a readout of Obama’s condolence call to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu from Air Force One, writes Natasha Mozgovaya from Haaretz. But, notes Mozgovaya, Mitt Romney was one of the first to issue a statement after the passing of Netanyahu’s father… Some voices in the Jewish community wondered in the past few days whether Obama would do the same… On Twitter, the Republican Jewish Coalition asked Wednesday: Obama also took three days to get around to it when it was [Turkish President] Erdogan who was bereaved, right?

In defense of Obama, according to Jewish Shiva laws non-family members are not suppose to give condolences until three days after the passing of the person. Perhaps Obama was sensitive to Jewish customs… But then again, close friends reach out to one another sooner than three days after a death in the family…

With Obama and Bibi Both Running, is 2012 a Replay of 1988 or 1992?

Ron Kampeas Writes: In 1988, the Dukakis-Bush race had no discernible effect on a race that saw Yitzhak Shamir edge Shimon Peres for Israel’s premiership. Four years later, however, Shamir’s contentious relationship with President George H. W. Bush is believed to have helped cost the Israeli prime minister the election.

So far, 2012 is looking more like ‘88 than ‘92, according to Aaron David Miller, a former longtime State Department Middle East negotiator who worked for the Bush administration.

“An Israeli prime minister is judged first and foremost by whether he can avoid catastrophic political decisions, then on the capacity to give Israelis a sense of security, then on the capacity to manage the U.S.-Israeli relationship,” said Miller, now a public policy fellow at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars.

Opinion: Romney Making Inroads With Jewish Voters

The AJC poll shows President Obama getting only 61 percent of the Jewish vote, a decline of 17 points down from the 78 percent he got in 2008. 11 percent are undecided, but when asked whom they are leaning towards, 5% picked Romney and 6% picked the president. Even before the Veep pick, the national convention, and the campaign effort which is expected to be aggressive and carefully area targeted in the months ahead, that gives Mitt Romney roughly 33% of the Jewish vote.

Based on this poll data, one could confidentially assume Mitt Romney getting around 39% of the Jewish vote in November. It matches President Reagan’s 1980-1984 support. Read more »

Why OBL Won’t Matter in November

Obama may give a Situation Room Interview regarding Osama Bin Laden and the Dems may boast about the success of this mission all week long, but in the context of the election is will play no role. Reasons being, the elections take place six months after the May First anniversary, and last year right after the actual raid, not only didn’t the President’s Approval Rating rise much, but it subsided pretty quickly. Therefore, in November when the news is ‘old,’ more people will give less attention to it, and instead they will focus on their job, income and gas prices, but for God-forbid if terror strikes again in the coming months. In that case, few will think Obama is doing a good job on Terror.

Iran’s Gift to Netanyahu

Alon Liel, a 30-year veteran of the country’s foreign ministry, where he once served as director general, told GlobalPost he believes the Iranian issue is expedient for Netanyahu both internationally and domestically. Abroad, he is vulnerable to accusations that he is not moving toward peace talks with the Palestinians. Internally, he needs to shore up his right flank ahead of elections. “In Netanyahu’s political circles, and even beyond that, it is very comfortable for him to lift the issue of Iran to high decibels. He needs to address internal political realities and consolidate an Israeli consensus, and also, internally and externally, to postpone the Palestinian issue,” he said. “He is much more comfortable talking about the Iranian danger than he is addressing the crisis with the Palestinians.” – Noga Tarnopolsky

On the Surface, Adelson and Soros are Strikingly Similar

David Efune writes in the Algemeiner about the politically-involved Jewish billionaires Sheldon Adelson and George Soros: Read more »

Why Obama Picked up More Votes in PA Yesterday Than Romney-Santorum Combined

“Romney grabbed the headlines Tuesday night, after winning the high-profile Pennsylvania Republican primary and four other northeastern-state GOP contests. but The president’s Democratic primary total was 150,000 votes ahead of Romney’s Republican primary total. In fact, Obama equaled that of Romney and Santorum combined,” writes The Nation. But then again, the Democrats had a few hotly contested House Primaries in Pennsylvania which draw many Registered Democrats to the poll and thus votes also for Obama.

Abusers? Perhaps. Suspects? Hell No!

The Forward requested from the Brooklyn DA to release a list of 85 Orthodox Jews who were arrested over the last three years on molestation charges. The DA’s office refused, writing “Because all of the requested defendant names relate to Hasidic men who are alleged to have committed sex crimes against Hasidic victims within a very tight-knit and insular Brooklyn community, there is a significant danger that the disclosure of the defendants’ names would lead members of that community to discern the identities of the victims.”

In other words, to protect victims the DA is shielding (alleged) abusers. Read more »

Looking at the Orthodox Jewish Vote for 2013 NYC Mayor Race

Colin Campbell Writes: Even though the community’s voters might side strongly with the Republican candidate in the 2013 mayoral race, they are mostly registered as Democrats and candidates seeking to win the Democratic primary are extensively courting the community.

“The community is very aware that the winner of the Democratic primary is likely to be the next mayor because of the current lack of a credible Republican candidate,” Councilman David Greenfield said when asked about the race. “As a result, I believe that you will see very high Orthodox Jewish turnout in the 2013 Democratic primary. The community also recognizes that if it’s a tight race, the seven or eight percentage points that the Orthodox Jewish vote makes up in a primary could definitely make the difference.” Read more »

GRAPH: Jewish House Membership to Decline in Next Congress

Shmuel Rosner Writes: Twenty-seven Jewish legislators were elected to the House in 2010. Not all of them will return next year. Some resigned, some intend to retire, some will be the victims of redistricting. All in all, we expect less Jewish legislators in next year’s House of Representatives. Projection: -4, meaning 23 Jewish Congressmen and women, and we still don’t see Republican House members other than Cantor getting in.

Despite Hysteria, Female Hasidic ‘Rebels’ Gain Custody of Their Children

There is an op-ed today in the NJ Star Ledger by Friday Reiss headlined “Among N.J. Orthodox Jewish women, child custody fears form barrier to freedom.”

In it, the author laments the fact that if a Hasidic woman tries to dress in what is considered amongst Hasidim as immodest, she will be secluded from the Community. The writer wants readers to believe that this is a sort of Hasidic oppression of women when in fact Hasidic men too are required to comply with modest dress codes. Besides, the concept of dress-code is not exclusive to the Hasidic Community. Specific dress codes are required at many schools, churches, dinners, and are a component of professional work place rules. Indeed, Hasidim are stricter with this concept, but Snooki can’t show up at a black-tie dinner in Jersey Shore-type attire expecting not to draw the ire of the organizers and most attendees. Read more »

Opinion: Diplomacy Will Dampen Iran War Talk

Justyna Pawlak Writes: Renewed diplomacy on Iran’s nuclear program will muffle what Barack Obama last month called the “drums of war”, but the beat will soon get louder if warm words do not lead swiftly to action that can defuse the decade-old dispute. Read more »

In 45 Words: Why ‘Out of State Contributions’ Should be Encouraged

Simple. More than 90% people affected by actions of Federal-level lawmakers live outside the state or outside the district represented by… lawmakers. As such, it should be welcome, not ridiculed, when a candidate or sitting lawmakers raises most of his/her funds out of state, meaning from the people that will be affected by the actions of this lawmaker.

.@RickSantorum Writes: Jerusalem is the capital of Israel

In a NYDN Op-Ed a day before he dropped out of the race, Rick Santorum wrote as follows: There is, sadly, a huge divide between the Obama  administration’s position and that of the government of Israel with regard  to Jerusalem.

For thousands of years, at the end of the Passover Seder as well as at the  end of Yom Kippur, Jews around the world conclude their holiday by reciting, “Next Year in Jerusalem.” Read more »